Thursday, November 19, 2026
HomeLatest NewsCJEU Avoids Ruling on Malta’s Controversial Bill 55

CJEU Avoids Ruling on Malta’s Controversial Bill 55

The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has refused to decide whether Malta’s controversial Bill 55 is compatible with EU law, rejecting a request for a preliminary ruling in the Spielerschutz Sigma case. This decision is good news for Malta-licensed operators. However, it does not resolve the growing disputes over the legislation and its impact on players seeking to recoup gambling losses.

Malta Continues to Shield Locally Licensed Operators

The newest case centered on Malta’s controversial legislation, known as Bill 55. It allows Maltese courts to ignore certain foreign judgments against locally licensed gambling operators, as long as these judgments concern activities that breach Malta’s gambling laws. The provision has faced criticism from players, legal representatives, and other stakeholders who say it undermines the EU’s system of judicial cooperation.

This case reached the ECJ after Austrian litigation finance firm Spielerschutz Sigma sought damages from its legal advisors in the Commercial Court in Vienna. The company sued Maltese gambling companies, securing several wins for players seeking compensation. While the advisors insisted that Bill 55 was incompatible with EU law and would allow enforcement proceedings in Malta, the reality was different.

A Maltese court rejected Spielerschutz Sigma’s petition to apply the Austrian court’s decisions to locally-licensed operators, leaving affected players with no way to obtain the compensation they were entitled to. As a result, the company sought compensation from its advisors, asking to recover fees and losses incurred after the allegedly misleading opinions.

A Definitive Ruling May Arrive Soon

The CJEU’s final ruling avoided the crux of the matter. In its November 19 judgment, the court ruled that the request was inadmissible. It argued that the dispute centered on whether the legal advice was reasonably defensible in light of the information available at the time it was given. That assessment could be made without considering whether Malta’s legislation aligned with EU requirements.

The lawfulness and proper performance of the reciprocal obligations of the parties to the legal consultation at issue are independent of the question of the compatibility of the relevant Maltese legislation with EU law.

CJEU ruling

This outcome is a significant win for Malta’s gambling industry, which relies heavily on Bill 55 to deflect legal challenges. An adverse ruling could have weakened operators’ ability to rely on the legislation to defend against foreign claims. However, the judgment should not be interpreted as confirmation that the law is valid. The CJEU simply refused to resolve the central legal question.

The ongoing legal drama surrounding Article 55 matters to many European players who lost money with operators that previously offered unlicensed gambling in countries like Austria. Many have sought compensation in national courts, arguing that their agreements with operators were invalid because the companies were operating without authorization. With several other legal challenges underway, EU courts may soon be forced to tackle this prickly subject.

RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular

Recent Comments