A federal judge has dismissed a six-year challenge brought by the Cherokee Nation, Chickasaw Nation, Choctaw Nation and Citizen Potawatomi Nation against gaming compacts Gov. Kevin Stitt signed with the Comanche Nation and Otoe-Missouria Tribe of Indians in 2020.
U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly ruled that the four plaintiff tribes lacked standing because they had not shown an actual or imminent injury that the court could remedy.
“The court concludes that plaintiffs lack standing for any of their claims because they have failed to show that they have suffered a redressable injury in fact that was caused by the secretary’s approval of the subject compacts,” Kelly wrote. “Plaintiffs assert several possible theories of standing to challenge the secretary’s approval of the subject compacts — competitor standing, equal footing standing, and economic harm — but each comes up short.”
The dismissal ends the federal case without deciding whether the agreements comply with the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act.
Judge Rejects Claims of Competitive Harm
Stitt signed the compacts in April 2020 during a wider dispute over Oklahoma’s tribal gaming framework. The agreements differed from the state’s model compact. They included a flat 4.5% revenue-sharing rate for most gaming at existing casinos and contained provisions covering house-banked card and table games, sports betting and up to six additional casinos, subject to further approvals.
The plaintiff tribes argued that the terms gave the Comanche and Otoe-Missouria tribes competitive advantages.
Kelly found those claimed injuries too uncertain because several depended on future changes in Oklahoma law. “Plaintiffs’ economic injury is contingent on an independent action — a change in Oklahoma law — that might (or might not) ever happen,” Kelly wrote. “So their injury in fact is ‘simply too attenuated and speculative’ to support competitor standing.”
Sports betting and some other gaming contemplated by the agreements remain prohibited in Oklahoma.
Kelly also rejected claims tied to the existing casinos operated by the two defendant tribes, noting that those properties were already in operation before the disputed compacts took effect.
The plaintiffs further argued that lower revenue-sharing obligations could allow their competitors to offer larger jackpots or better amenities. Kelly found insufficient evidence to establish that such spending would occur.
Six Proposed Casinos Were Not Imminent
The compacts also provide for the governor’s support in taking land into trust for as many as three additional casinos for each tribe. Kelly said those potential developments might have supported standing if they were close to becoming reality.
“In fact, the construction of any new casino depends on another intervening development: the land being ‘taken into trust’ for the subject tribes,” Kelly wrote. “And this is a lengthy process which requires the consent of the secretary, would likely face legal challenge, and has not begun.”
The agreements also established new exclusivity fee rates and quarterly reporting requirements to the Oklahoma Office of Management and Enterprise Services.
The U.S. Department of the Interior allowed the compacts to take effect in 2020 after then-Interior Secretary David Bernhardt did not act within the statutory 45-day review period.
The four tribes later challenged that outcome, arguing that the agreements were invalid under federal law because Oklahoma had not lawfully entered into them.
State-Law Ruling Remains Separate
Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond supported the plaintiff tribes through a friend-of-the-court brief filed in 2025.
According to The Journal Record, Drummond argued that Stitt lacked the “actual authority to bind the state” and pointed to the Oklahoma Supreme Court’s Treat v. Stitt decision. He also maintained that it was “undisputed that the compacts were not ‘lawfully entered into’ by the state of Oklahoma.”
The Oklahoma Supreme Court ruled in July 2020 that Stitt exceeded his authority by signing agreements that authorized gambling activities prohibited under state law without legislative approval.
Kelly’s ruling does not alter that state-court decision. It also leaves unanswered the separate federal question of whether the Comanche and Otoe-Missouria compacts comply with the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act.
The case therefore ends on standing grounds rather than on the merits of the compacts themselves.
