A total of nine Democratic senators, led by California’s Adam Schiff, want the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to reverse a recent move that could potentially boost prediction market access across the United States.
Their argument: the agency is undermining state and tribal gambling laws.
“Unilateral Decision” Goes Against Court Orders
In a letter sent at the start of the week to CFTC’s chairman Michael Selig, the nine lawmakers decided to challenge the commission’s November 5 interpretation directing designated contract markets (DCMs) to stop geofencing certain event-contract markets.
The change effectively requires prediction market platforms to make their contracts available in all 50 states and on tribal lands, despite existing court orders that prohibit access in several jurisdictions.
The senators claimed that the CFTC’s position is in direct conflict with the ongoing legal proceedings, adding that it could stimulate platforms to offer sports-related contracts in places where courts have already ordered them to block access.
“Your unilateral decision directly conflicts with active court orders, undermines state and tribal law, and must be reversed,” the lawmakers wrote.
The letter was also signed by Senators Catherine Cortez Masto and Jacky Rosen of Nevada, Maria Cantwell and Patty Murray of Washington, Elissa Slotkin and Gary Peters of Michigan, Alex Padilla of California, and Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota.
Geofencing Required in Four States
Court orders currently require prediction market operators to geofence sports event contracts in California, Michigan, Nevada and Washington, including restrictions covering tribal reservations.
The senators pointed particularly to a September ruling by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in Blue Lake Rancheria v. Kalshi, when the court unanimously found that Kalshi’s sports event contracts likely represented unauthorized Class III gaming under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act when offered on tribal lands.
The case involved the Blue Lake Rancheria and Chicken Ranch of Me-Wuk Indians. According to court findings, the tribes had a good chance to succeed in their claims against Kalshi and Polymarket.
The lawmakers questioned why the CFTC issued its interpretation just hours after the appeals court ruling, warning that the agency could be encouraging companies involved in active litigation to disregard state and tribal restrictions.
They asked Selig to withdraw the interpretation or suspend its implementation until all ongoing court cases would be resolved while also requesting that the commission preserve all relevant communications and records dating back to January 1, 2025, and confirm compliance by November 23.
Selig, however, was not eager to back down. During an interview with CNBC, he said the CFTC believes it has exclusive authority over prediction markets and is prepared to take the dispute to the Supreme Court if necessary.
He also went on to criticize states that are pursuing criminal cases against prediction market executives, saying that companies operating under federal oversight should not face the threat of imprisonment over disagreements about whether their products represent gambling or financial derivatives.
His comments followed Utah Attorney General Derek Brown‘s decision to file 14 criminal charges against Kalshi co-founders Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara, including 13 felony counts, alleging violations of state anti-gambling laws.
